A Rare Find Among the Migrants at Second Mountain Hawk Watch

Yesterday morning’s fallout of hundreds of nocturnally migrating birds was followed overnight by the influx of one hundred or more new arrivals atop Second Mountain in Lebanon County, Pennsylvania.  Visitors to the forest clearing used as a hawk watch lookout were treated to the antics of these colorful Neotropical species and more…

Red-eyed Vireo
…Red-eyed Vireo,…
A Great Crested Flycatcher.
…Great Crested Flycatcher,…
Least Flycatcher
…Least Flycatcher,…
A Northern Parula.
…Northern Parula,…
Juvenile Northern Paula
…juvenile Northern Paula,…
Nashville Warblers
…and quarrelsome Nashville Warblers.

These night-flying warblers, vireos, and flycatchers did again provide a thrilling show during the hours after sunrise, but today’s rarity passed through among the hundreds of migrating diurnal raptors—the tropics-bound Broad-winged Hawks—that made their way down the ridges of the lower Susquehanna valley this afternoon.

"Kettling" Broad-winged Hawks
A “kettle” of Broad-winged Hawks climbing on a thermal updraft above Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
Broad-winged Hawks
After gaining altitude, Broad-winged Hawks glide away toward the southwest in search of the next thermal updraft upon which they will rise to continue their journey to Texas, Mexico, and beyond.  Over three hundred of these raptors were counted as they passed the Second Mountain lookout today.
"Kettling" Broad-winged Hawks
Another “kettling” flock of migrating Broad-winged Hawks above Second Mountain.
Light-morph and dark-morph Broad-winged Hawks
A closer look reveals something unusual.  While the Broad-winged Hawk at the bottom center of the image displays the typical light-morph plumage, the bird in the upper left appears to be a dark-morph Broad-winged Hawk, a rarity in the eastern United States.
Dark-morph Broad-winged Hawk
A zoomed-in view of the probable dark-morph Broad-winged Hawk seen over Second Mountain this afternoon.  Populations of these variants nest in areas of central and western Canada.

The peak of the autumn Broad-winged Hawk migration will likely occur during the coming two weeks with many counting stations tallying more than one thousand birds on the best of days.  Visit one of these prominent lookout points so that you too can witness this amazing spectacle.  Click the “Hawkwatcher’s Helper: Identifying Bald Eagles and other Diurnal Raptors” tab at the top of this page to find a hawk watch near you!

Pot o’ Gold on the Ridgetops

Bathed in glowing sunshine, a very large fallout of migrating Neotropical songbirds enlivened the forest edge atop Second Mountain in northern Lebanon County, Pennsylvania, this morning.  While last night’s flight was widespread beneath a dome of atmospheric high pressure covering the Mid-Atlantic States, this is a look at some of the 500 -1,000 migrants observed feeding on insects and other natural foods at just this single location.

Blackpoll and Black-throated Green Warblers
As the composition of the nightly flights begins to transition to species that start their migration later in the season, numbers of birds like the Blackpoll Warbler (top) are beginning to rival those of the heretofore very common Black-throated Green Warbler (bottom).
Blackpoll Warbler
A Blackpoll Warbler.
Bay-breasted Warbler
The Bay-breasted Warbler, another common species found among the fallout flock.
Tennessee Warbler
The Tennessee Warbler was today’s most abundant migrant with at least 200 birds seen moving among the other species.
Tennessee Warbler
A newly arrived Tennessee Warbler at sunrise.
Tennessee Warbler
A Tennessee Warbler snatches breakfast.
Magnolia Warbler
The Magnolia Warbler was another common find among today’s migrants.
Magnolia Warbler
A Magnolia Warbler.
Nashville Warbler
A Nashville Warbler among tangles of Mile-a-minute Weed.
Nashville Warbler
A Nashville Warbler.
Black-throated Blue Warbler
Black-throated Blue Warbler.
Adult Male Black-throated Blue Warbler
An adult male Black-throated Blue Warbler.
Northern Parula
An acrobatic Northern Parula.
Blackburnian Warbler
Blackburnian Warblers continue their southerly trek.
American Redstart
An American Redstart.
 Chestnut-sided Warbler
A Chestnut-sided Warbler feeding on Mile-a-minute Weed berries.
 Cape May Warbler
A Cape May Warbler.
Adult Male Cape May Warbler
A handsome adult male Cape May Warbler.
Swainson's Thrush
A Swainson’s Thrush.
Scarlet Tanager
Scarlet Tanagers continue to work their way south through the Lower Susquehanna River Watershed.
Olive-sided Flycatcher
A composite image of an uncommon find, a large-headed Olive-sided Flycatcher seen perched atop a dead tree snag.
Philadelphia Vireo
A brief encounter with a Philadelphia Vireo, another uncommon species.
Blue-headed Vireo
A Blue-headed Vireo, typically the last of its genus to move south in the fall, put in a welcome appearance among the hundreds of migrants.
Ruby-throated Hummingbird
A favorite diurnal migrant, the Ruby-throated Hummingbird, was seen feeding on flowers that grew from the remains of garden waste dumped illegally along the mountain road last autumn.

Many of the observers at the Second Mountain Hawk Watch commented that this morning’s fallout was by far the best they had seen anywhere in the region during recent years.  Others believed it to be the best they had ever seen.  It was indeed less like a “wave” of migrants and more like a “tsunami”.  Choosing a good viewing location and being there at the right time can improve your chances of seeing a spectacle like this.  The good news is, it looks like another big flight is currently underway, so finding a forest edge on a ridgetop or along a utility right-of-way just might pay off for you early tomorrow morning.

Nocturnal migrating birds, a southwest-bound flight down the ridges of central Pennsylvania as indicated by Doppler radar between 10:30 and 11:30 PM EDT on September 11, 2024.  (NOAA/National Weather Service image)

This Week’s Review of the Morning Fallouts

Clear, cool nights have provided ideal flight conditions for nocturnal Neotropical migrants and other southbound birds throughout the week.  Fix yourself a drink and a little snack, then sit down and enjoy this set of photographs that includes just some of the species we found during sunrise feeding frenzies atop several of the Lower Susquehanna River Watershed’s ridges.  Hurry up, because here they come…

Black-throated Green Warbler
A Black-throated Green Warbler.
Black-throated Green Warbler
The Black-throated Green Warbler was perhaps the most frequently identified treetop warbler during the most recent four mornings.
Black-throated Green Warbler
A Black-throated Green Warbler with a unique variation in the crown plumage.
Blackburnian Warbler
The Blackburnian Warbler was another plentiful species.
Blackburnian Warbler
A Blackburnian Warbler feeding in a Red Maple.
Cape May Warblers
Cape May Warblers have an affinity for conifers like this Eastern White Pine.
Cape May Warbler
But when traveling in mixed flocks with other migrants, Cape May Warblers can also be found feeding in the crown foliage of deciduous trees.
Tennessee Warbler
This adult Tennessee Warbler appears to be adorned in a very worn set of plumage…
Tennessee Warbler
…and its traveling companion looks like it’s overdue for a new set of feathers as well.
Nashville Warbler
Like the Tennessee Warbler, the Nashville Warbler was common among mixed flocks.
Nashville Warbler
A Nashville Warbler atop a Black Cherry.
Chestnut-sided Warbler
This Chestnut-sided Warbler was one of several found among the more common species of migrants.
Chestnut-sided Warbler
A Chestnut-sided Warbler.
Chestnut-sided Warbler
We were lucky enough to spot this male Chestnut-sided Warbler sporting his namesake flank feathers.
 Black-and-white Warbler
A Black-and-white Warbler uses its nuthatch-like feeding behavior to search the tree bark for edible invertebrates.
Common Yellowthroat
To see the Common Yellowthroat, one must cease looking upward into the high canopy and instead give the aching neck a rest by peering into the low vegetation at the forest edge.
Magnolia Warbler
While checking the low growth, keep an eye open for other migrants among the shrubs and tangles. This Magnolia Warbler glows in the rays of a rising sun as it searches for a meal after a long night of travel.
House Wren
Here we found a perky little House Wren.
Eastern Wood-Pewee
Back in the middle and upper reaches of the trees, we find what has been by far the most numerous of the flycatchers seen during our visits to fallout sunrises.  Eastern Wood-Pewees are appearing in very good numbers and can be seen quarreling and battling for hunting perches from which they are ambushing flying insects.
 Eastern Wood-Pewee
An Eastern Wood-Pewee fiercely defending its hunting perch.
Eastern Wood-Pewee
An Eastern Wood-Pewee.
Least Flycatcher
The numbers of migrating Least Flycatchers and other members of the genus Empidonax may be reaching their seasonal peak this week.
Scarlet Tanagers
Scarlet Tanagers are currently a common find following nocturnal flights.
Scarlet Tanager
A Scarlet Tanager peers down from the top of a Red Maple.
Rose-breasted Grosbeak
Did you hear a loud squeak in the treetops?  It could be a southbound Rose-breasted Grosbeak stopping by for the day.
Rose-breasted Grosbeak
A Rose-breasted Grosbeak in a dead tree snag.
Swainson's Thrush
The Neotropical thrushes are beginning to move south now as well.  We found this newly arrived Swainson’s Thrush at Rocky Ridge County Park in York County during sunrise this morning.
Red-eyed Vireo
Not surprisingly, the Red-eyed Vireo is one of the most numerous of the migrants seen feeding in the deciduous canopy following a nocturnal flight event.  It’s not at all unusual to see dozens filing the trees around a ridgetop overlook or along a forest edge.  Be certain to check these congregations carefully, especially the groups of birds feeding in the lower branches of tall timber or in the tops of smaller trees.  This week we found…
Yellow-throated Vireo
…several hungry Yellow-throated Vireos arriving after nocturnal flights,…
Philadelphia Vireo
…and a Philadelphia Vireo (Vireo philadelphicus) at the hawkwatch at Rocky Ridge County Park in York County.
Red-breasted Nuthatch
Though not a Neotropical migrant, the easier-heard-than-seen Red-breasted Nuthatch is beginning to wander south into the lower Susquehanna region.  Most of these birds will eventually continue on to the pine forests of the southern United States for winter, but a few could remain to become seasonal visitors at feeding stations.
Ruby-throated Hummingbird
Ruby-throated Hummingbirds are on the move; their migration to the tropics is well underway and nearing its peak.  Ruby-throats are diurnal migrants that do a majority of their flying during the hours of daylight.  The notable exception: the nighttime portion of the long southbound flight some of the birds make to cross the Gulf of Mexico.
Red-headed Woodpecker
The Red-headed Woodpecker is another diurnal migrant.   This denizen of temperate climates is currently beginning to move to its wintering grounds, an area that extends from the latitudes of the lower Susquehanna south to the Gulf of Mexico and central Texas.
Juvenile Red-headed Woodpecker
A juvenile Red-headed Woodpecker during a brief pit stop.
Cedar Waxwings
The flights of roving bands of masked Cedar Waxwings continue.  Their numbers appear to be an improvement over those of 2023.
Broad-winged Hawk
At regional hawk-counting stations, observers are seeing more Broad-winged Hawks and other species beginning to move through.
"Kettling" Broad-winged Hawks
The frequency of Broad-winged Hawks passing the lookouts one at a time is giving way to the occurrence of larger and larger “kettling” groups that search out thermal updrafts to save energy while migrating.  By mid-September each of these “kettles” can include one hundred birds or more.  On the peak days, the daily Broad-winged Hawk totals can reach one thousand or more.
Broad-winged Hawk
A Broad-winged Hawk soaring to gain lift from a thermal updraft above a hawkwatch lookout.

The migration is by no means over; it has only just begun.  So plan to visit a local hawkwatch or other suitable ridgetop in coming weeks.  Arrive early (between 7 and 8 AM) to catch a glimpse of a nocturnal migrant fallout, then stay through the day to see the hundreds, maybe even thousands, of Broad-winged Hawks and other diurnal raptors that will pass by.  It’s an experience you won’t forget.

Broad-winged Hawk Gliding Away to the Southwest
A Broad-winged Hawk gliding away to the southwest.

Be certain to click the “Birds” tab at the top of this page for a photo guide to the species you’re likely to see passing south through the lower Susquehanna valley in coming months.  And don’t forget to click the “Hawkwatcher’s Helper: Identifying Bald Eagles and other Diurnal Raptors” tab to find a hawk-counting station near you.

More birds are on the way.  Here’s a look at this evening’s liftoff of nocturnal migrants detected by National Weather Service Radar in State College, Pennsylvania.  (NOAA/National Weather Service Doppler Radar image)

Surf’s Up: The Waves Keep Rolling In

“Waves” of warblers and other Neotropical songbirds continue to roll along the ridgetops of southern Pennsylvania.  The majority of these migrants are headed to wintering habitat in the tropics after departing breeding grounds in the forests of southern Canada.  At Second Mountain Hawk Watch, today’s early morning flight kicked off at sunrise, then slowed considerably by 8:30 A.M. E.D.T.  Once again, in excess of 400 warblers were found moving through the trees and working their way southwest along the spine of the ridge.  Each of the 12 species seen yesterday were observed today as well.  In addition, there was a Northern Parula and a Canada Warbler.  Today’s flight was dominated by Bay-breasted, Blackburnian, Black-throated Green, and Tennessee Warblers.

A Blackburnian Warbler at sunrise on Second Mountain.
A Blackburnian Warbler at sunrise on Second Mountain.
A hungry Blackburnian Warbler feeding on insects.
A hungry Blackburnian Warbler feeding on insects.
Black-throated Green Warbler on Second Mountain.
Black-throated Green Warblers were a plentiful species among both yesterday’s and today’s waves of Neotropical migrants.
A juvenile Black-throated Green Warbler on Second Mountain
A juvenile Black-throated Green Warbler.
Tennessee Warbler on Second Mountain.
One of the scores of Tennessee Warblers seen on Second Mountain early this morning.
Cape May Warbler
Cape May Warblers were still common today, but not moving through in the numbers seen yesterday.
A male Black-throated Blue Warbler on Second Mountain.
A male Black-throated Blue Warbler.
Magnolia Warbler on Second Mountain.
Compared to yesterday’s flight, lesser numbers of Magnolia Warblers were seen today.
An adult male Wilson's Warbler on Second Mounatin.
An adult male Wilson’s Warbler was a good find among the hundreds of birds swarming the ridgetop.
Nashville Warbler
This Nashville Warbler spent much of the day in the tangles of Mile-a-minute Weed surrounding the lookout.

Other interesting Neotropical migrants joined the “waves” of warblers…

Red-eyed Vireo
Red-eyed Vireo numbers were higher than yesterday.
Warbling Vireo
This Warbling Vireo was found peering from the cover of the shady forest.
Rose-breasted Grosbeaks
A minimum of six Rose-breasted Grosbeaks were identified including the juvenile male seen here in first-fall plumage.  Other good sightings were Scarlet Tanagers, an adult male Baltimore Oriole, and a dozen or more Ruby-throated Hummingbirds.
Least Flycatcher on second Mountain.
Three Least Flycatchers were heard calling and seen chasing one another through a stand of dead timber on the south slope below the lookout.
Broad-winged Hawk
After the warbler flight settled, the task of counting migrating raptors commenced.  Five Broad-winged Hawks including this one were tallied as they glided away to the southwest for a winter vacation in the tropics of Central and South America.

Catch a Wave While You’re Sittin’ on Top of the World

During the recent couple of mornings, a tide of Neotropical migrants has been rolling along the crests of the Appalachian ridges and Piedmont highlands of southern Pennsylvania.  In the first hours of daylight, “waves” of warblers, vireos, flycatchers, tanagers, and other birds are being observed flitting among the sun-drenched foliage as they feed in trees along the edges of ridgetop clearings.  Big fallouts have been reported along Kittattiny Ridge/Blue Mountain at Hawk Mountain Sanctuary and at Waggoner’s Gap Hawk Watch.  Birds are also being seen in the Furnace Hills of the Piedmont.

Here are some of the 300 to 400 warblers (a very conservative estimate) seen in a “wave” found working its way southwest through the forest clearing at the Second Mountain Hawk Watch in Lebanon County this morning.  The feeding frenzy endured for two hours between 7 and 9 A.M. E.D.T.

Tennessee Warblers at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
Tennessee Warblers (Leiothlypis peregrina) were very common among the migrants seen this morning on Second Mountain.
Tennessee Warbler at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
An adult male Tennessee Warbler.
Nashville Warbler at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
A Nashville Warbler.
Chestnut-sided Warbler at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
A Chestnut-sided Warbler.
Cape May Warbler at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
Cape May Warblers were another common species during the morning flight.
Magnolia Warbler at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
Magnolia Warblers were frequently observed as well.
Black-and-white Warbler at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
A Black-and-white Warbler exhibiting its nuthatch-like feeding behavior.
Blackburnian Warbler at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
A Blackburnian Warbler.
Black-throated Green Warbler at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
Black-throated Green Warblers were numerous.
Bay-breasted Warbler at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
A Bay-breasted Warbler.
Wilson's Warbler at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
This was the only Wilson’s Warbler discerned among the hundreds of warblers seen in a “wave” on Second Mountain this morning.

Not photographed but observed in the mix of species were several Black-throated Blue Warblers and American Redstarts.

In addition to the warblers, other Neotropical migrants were on the move including two Common Nighthawks, a Broad-winged Hawk, a Least Flycatcher (Empidonax minimus), and…

Scarlet Tanager at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
At least half a dozen Scarlet Tanagers were in the treetops.
Ruby-throated Hummingbird at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
And no less than 23 Ruby-throated Hummingbirds were counted cruising southbound past the lookout at Second Mountain Hawk Watch today.

Then, there was a taste of things to come…

Red-breasted Nuthatch at Second Mountain Hawk Watch.
One of 3 Red-breasted Nuthatches filling the air on the mountaintop with calls reminiscent of a toy tin horn.  Will this summer’s forest fires in Canada prompt a significant invasion of this and other birds including winter finches in coming months?  Time will tell.

Seeing a “wave” flight is a matter of being in the right place at the right time.  Visiting known locations for observing warbler fallouts such as hawk watches, ridgetop clearings, and peninsular shorelines can improve your chances of witnessing one of these memorable spectacles by overcoming the first variable.  To overcome the second, be sure to visit early and often.  See you on the lookout!

Big Fallout

Okay, so it happened to be cloudy with drizzle at sunrise—not the best conditions for observing birds in the treetops.  But that inclement weather effectively grounded the overnight flight of migrating songbirds leading to a really big fallout in the lower Susquehanna valley this morning.

While straining one’s neck to gaze up into the forest canopy, hundreds of migrants including warblers, vireos, tanagers, thrushes, and flycatchers could be seen.  Identifying each was impossible.

Here are of few of this morning’s arrivals.  Manually setting the camera to a slower shutter speed compensated a little bit for the backlighting caused by cloudy conditions.

Pine Warbler (Setophaga pinus).
Bay-breasted Warbler.
Black-throated Green Warbler.
Nashville Warbler (Leiothlypis ruficapilla).
Northern Parula (Setophaga americana).

Peak numbers of Broad-winged Hawks will pass through the area during the coming two weeks.  They most often migrate in groups, with sizes ranging from several individuals to hundreds or even thousands of birds.  Despite this being a less than ideal day for riding thermals and gliding off towards the southwest to continue their journey to the tropics, some “broad-wings” ventured aloft and were on their way soon after the drizzle subsided during mid-morning.

A Broad-winged Hawk lifts off from the cover of the forest where it spent the night.
The same Broad-winged Hawk (bottom) and an adult Bald Eagle gain altitude on a thermal updraft before the former glides away toward the southwest.

Harvey Passes By

Rain from the remnants of Hurricane/Tropical Storm Harvey ended just after daybreak this morning.  Locally, the precipitation was mostly absorbed into the soil.   There was little runoff and no flooding.  The river level at Conewago Falls is presently as low as it has been all summer.  Among the pools and rapids of the Pothole Rocks, numbers of migrating birds are building.

Mist and a low cloud ceiling created poor visibility while trying to see early morning birds, but they’re here.  The warblers are moving south and a small wave of them was filtering through the foliage on the edge of the Riparian Woodlands.  One must bend backwards to have a look, and most could not be identified due to the poor lighting in the crowns of the trees where they were zipping about.  Five species of warblers and two species of vireos were discerned.

There are increasing concentrations of swallows feeding on insects over the falls.  Hundreds were here today, mostly Tree Swallows (Tachycineta bicolor).  Bank Swallows (Stelgidopteryx riparia) numbered in the hundreds, far below the thousands, often 10,000, which staged here for migration and peaked during the first week of September annually during the 1980s and 1990s.  Their numbers have been falling steadily.  Loss of nesting locations in embankments near water may be impacting the entire population.  A reduction in the abundance of late-summer flying insects here on the lower Susquehanna River may be cause for them to abandon this area as a migration staging point.

Bank and Tree Swallows by the hundreds were feeding upon flying insects above the waters of Conewago Falls today.  Lesser numbers of Northern Rough-winged Swallows (Stelgidopteryx serripennis) and Barn Swallows (Hirundo rustica) joined the swarm.

Clear weather in the coming nights and days may get the migrants up and flying in large numbers.  For those species headed to the tropics for winter, the time to get moving has arrived.

CLICK ON THE LOGO FOR TODAY’S MIGRATION COUNT TOTALS